Skip to main content

New Problems Require New Solutions


You're wrong about Common Core math: Sorry, parents, but it makes ...Ah yes, I'm sure we've all seen this or similar postings around the internet - the famous "too smart for elementary school" parent who's really "showing those teachers".
The problem I see here is a parent who despite his MANY years of education, failed.
He failed to read directions.
He failed to answer the question being asked.

Without knowing what grade level this problem is aimed at (I'm assuming 1st or 2nd grade), the problem here is not that "math has changed". The problem is that the problems have changed.

This highly educated parent (and many of those educated as much or less who see and share this) all fail to see that the question is NOT 427-316 = ???

Instead, the question is demonstrating a method of subtraction (more on that strategy here) and asking what went wrong for the student. It's about error analysis.

I bet if Mr. Engineer Dad had seen the problem labeled Error Analysis his chest would've puffed with pride to see little Engineer Child learning such advanced math.
And yet, when it's demonstrated at an elementary school level Mr. Engineer can't figure out how to go backwards in time and imagine NOT knowing what he knows. Not once in his condescending explanation did he even mention that Jack forgot to subtract the 10. His child on the other hand probably counted the 3 100 jumps (300) and the 6 1 unit jumps (6) and realized that Jack only took away/moved back 306, not 316.

Math instruction is not JUST about finding answers. Gone are the days of math teachers preaching that you'll never have a calculator in your pocket - we KNOW you do! Now we ask students to explain their thinking (more on that next week) and locate errors in someone else's.  Why? Because THAT is what learning math is about. It's about knowing HOW to arrive at an answer given any circumstances and how to do so in the MOST EFFECTIVE way possible.
(FWIW - that sounds a lot like what the engineers I know do all day, every day.)


Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The sum is the same, no matter how you got there; so how'd you get there?

  Yet another example of adults saying "But there's a better way..."  No one would argue that you, adult, can add probably faster than an elementary school student.  We are in the process of building UP TO that speed and accuracy. By encouraging your child to imagine the groupings, you are building their imagination (draw whatever you'd like!), their math skills (count up, make 10s), and their mental flexibility ALL IN 1 PROBLEM!  Check out my NEW addition video for a little more about how this problem is VERY similar to what many adults already do! Making sense of a problem IRL isn't about having an algorithm to write out your work. Instead it's about applying what you know to a REAL situation.  This is what most adults think of when they see  an addition problem: But this is what many                                                ...
Post a Comment
Read more

It's about the learning not the grade.

  I hope you (and the children/students in your life) had the chance to watch the Perseverance land on Mars recently. Or see the Dragon launch last year. Every single one of the astronauts, engineers,  and technicians had years of schooling to prepare for THAT MOMENT. Every doctor or nurse has been trained through lectures, tests, and field experiences.  Something that strikes me every year around this time, as our seniors are making college decisions and our juniors are taking the ACT and beginning the application process, is that not one person in any interview I've ever had has asked me about my grades or GPA. We have tied up so much time and energy into thinking that only the best survive, but we KNOW that can't be true.  All that does is overstress our teens and lead them to believe that successful people never struggle. That is a damaging belief - especially when internalized by students who are struggling.  Here's my take on grades: 
Post a Comment
Read more

Tools for Now, Learning for Later

That quote, is SPOT ON! I don't disagree in the least. (Bet you didn't expect that, did you??) However, I don't know any elementary school students who are sent to the grocery store to do the weekly shopping on a budget alone.  Number lines, hundreds boards, ten frames, algebra tiles, and all the other physical representations of math and numbers give students something concrete to set the stage for learning. We move away from each of them fairly quickly as students become more fluent in their math facts, but they provide a perfect physical and visual reminder for students to mentally refer back to as they learn and grow.  We all encourage our kids to try new things - consider adding new math strategies to that list! (And cheer them on, just like you would if they were trying a new sport or instrument.) 
Post a Comment
Read more